B1
CELLS
CHRONIC LYMPHOCYTIC LEUKEMIA (B-CLL) / SMALL LYMPHOCYTIC LYMPHOMA (mildly
aggressive)
Table of contents :
Epidemiology
: CLL is the most frequent type of leukemia in the Western world and affects
mainly elderly individuals, but about a third of patients are < 60 years
of age at diagnosisref.
95% of all CLLs. Prevalence : 15:100,000.
Aetiology : risk
factors :
-
male gender
-
increasing age
-
ethnicity (high in Caucasians, lowest in Asians) and family history : migration
studies confirm that ethnic groups retain the risk associated with their
origin rather than their new location, favoring a role for heredity. Kindreds
with multiple cases of CLL have been well described in the literature and
studies in large populations confirm that lymphoproliferative malignancies
and especially CLL occur together at a rate that cannot be attributed to
chance. Since environmental factors cannot readily explain the familial
aggregations, a hereditary factor that affects susceptibility to CLL is
likely. The identification of clones that are immunophenotypically identical
to CLL in healthy individuals from CLL kindreds (14% to 18%) as well as
in the general population (3.5% in age bracket >65 years) suggests a possible
precursor condition, but longitudinal studies will be necessary to establish
significance in the general population. Family (linkage) and population
(candidate gene) studies to date have been too small to identify the specific
genes that account for increased susceptibility; larger studies including
planned consortia to identify additional high-risk kindreds for genetic
studies, as well as the application of advanced technologies such as genomics,
cytogenetic, expression, and proteomics, are widely expected to advance
understanding over the next few yearsref.
Some families show classic findings in support of an autosomal dominant
mode of genetic transmission of CLLref
-
farming and pesticide
exposure
-
ionizing radiation
exposureref
-
tobacco users and
cigarette smokers
(OR = 1.6)ref,
and environmental tobacco smoke (ETS) (OR = 2.3)ref.
Approximately 2% of patients with CLL develop lung
carcinoma
.
In a study, 85% of the patients were smokers. These patients had a high
risk of a third primary malignancy (including melanoma, basal cell carcinoma,
laryngeal carcinoma, and colon carcinoma). Lung carcinoma was diagnosed
a decade after CLL. Patients who develop both diseases die of lung carcinoma
and not CLL or other solid tumors. CLL and poor performance status limit
treatment, particularly for patients with unresectable lung carcinomaref
-
familal B-CLL : genetic basis in about
10% of patientsref.
The lifetime risk of developing CLL in first-degree relatives of patients
with the disease is increased by a factor of 8. The inherited predisposition
to CLL may be mediated by a gene with pleiotropic effects as suggested
by a two-fold increase, in relatives of CLL patients, of other B-cell disorders,
mostly NHL and HL. In fact, in our database of over 300 families with CLL
we have identified 12 with multiple myeloma in relativesref.
By analogy with MGUS, when healthy relatives from CLL families were examined
with sensitive flow cytometry methods, monoclonal B-cell lymphocytes are
detected with high frequencyref.
-
HLA-B8 is a marker of mild disease while HLA-A2 and the closely associated
antigens B12(44) and DR7 are markers for severe diseaseref
-
HLA B12, alone or in combination with HLA A2, indicated better prognosis.
Relatives HLA identical with the patients showed no evidence of white cell
disorder when compared with haplo- or non-identical relatives, or controls.
As a group, however, relatives of patients had fewer lymphocytes than relatives
of controlsref
-
an increased incidence of lymphoid malignancy has been reported in western
Ashkenazi Jews and in particular those of Russian descent.ref
Pathogenesis :
|
IgVH unmutated B-CLL (U-CLL) (intraclonal variation
< 95%) (50%)
|
IgVH mutated B-CLL (M-CLL) (50%)
|
| intraclonal variation (ongoing SHM) |
absent or very low |
low |
| morphology |
atypical according to the criteria of Matutes et alref
as > 10% (but < 55%) prolymphocytes or > 15% cells with cleaved nuclei
and/or lymphoplasmacytoid cells in the peripheral blood of patients
whose predominant cell type was a small lymphocyte with coarsely clumped
chromatin (dense cells (DC) / Rieder's cell or lymphocyte (a myeloblast
whose nucleus with wide and deep indentations suggesting lobulation, which
may represent asynchronism of nuclear and cytoplasmic maturation)) |
typical (Gumprecht
shadow or basket cells (BC)
are highly suggestiveref1,
ref2) |
| stage at diagnosis |
advanced (C) |
early (A, B) |
| cell source |
pregerminal center naive B-cells |
germinal center exposed B-cells |
| CD38 |
high (> 30%) |
low (< 30%) |
| ZAP70ref |
high (> 20%)ref1,
ref2 |
low (< 20%) |
| chromosomal aberrations |
+12, del(11q), del(17p) |
normal or del(13q14) (which contains 2 small miRNA genes that are turned
off in about 60% of CLL cases) |
| miRNA signatureref |
reduced expression of miR-16 |
reduced expression of miR-16 |
| therapy |
poor response |
good response |
| survival |
average life expectancy of about 8 years and is universally fatal |
average survival of 25 years and most people with this form die of
other causes rather than of CLL) |
There is a bias in the use of certain VH, D, and JH
genes among B-CLL cells. VH genes of ~ 50% of the IgM+
B-CLL cells and ~ 75% of the non-IgM+ B-CLL cells can exhibit
somatic mutations according to the VH family expressed by the
B-CLL cell (VH3 expressers displaying more mutation than VH1
and VH4 expressers). In addition, the extent of mutation can
be sizeable with ~ 32% of the IgM+ cases and ~ 68% of the non-IgM+
cases differing by > 5% from the most similar germline gene. Approximately
20% of the mutated VH genes display replacement mutations in
a pattern consistent with antigen selection. However, CDR3 characteristics
(D and JH gene use and association and HCDR3 length, composition,
and charge) suggest that selection for distinct BCR occurs in many more
B-CLL cells. Many B-CLL cells have been previously stimulated, placing
them in the "experienced" or "memory" CD5+ B cell subset.
-
a restricted set of variable (V) region genes, specifically VH1-69
(also known as 51p1) and Vk3-A27
(also known as kv325), which bind to
HCV
E2 envelope protein, occurs in 10-20% of patientsref1,
ref2.
Preferential use of the 51p1 gene has also been observed in CLL, with a
prevalence of > 20% in particular geographic areasref.
However, unlike the HCV-associated immunocytomas, the 51p1 VH
sequences in CLL are almost exclusively unmutated and usually have significantly
longer CDR3 regionsref1,
ref2.
VH1-69 B-CLLs constitute a uniform group of patients that more
often present at advanced clinical stages and require early treatment,
but their survival does not differ significantly from patients with other
unmutated VH genesref.
-
cutaneous manifestations of B-CLL comprise a wide spectrum of clinicopathologic
presentations. In some cases, onset of skin lesions is triggered by antigenic
stimulation, and specific skin infiltrates at sites of previous herpes
simplex or herpes zoster infection have been well documented. Specific
skin manifestations of B-CLL can also be observed at sites typical for
lymphadenosis benigna cutis (nipple, scrotum, earlobe), a Borrelia
burgdorferi
-associated
cutaneous B-cell pseudolymphoma. Histology of solitary erythematous
plaques or nodules located on the nipple (4 cases) and scrotum (2 cases)
from 6 patients with B-CLL (M : F = 4 : 2; mean age: 67.8) revealed in
all cases a dense, monomorphous infiltrate of small lymphocytes showing
an aberrant CD20+/CD43+ phenotype. In all cases monoclonality
was demonstrated by PCR analysis of the JH gene rearrangement.
PCR analysis showed in four of the six cases the presence of DNA sequences
specific for B.burgdorferi. Infection with B. burgdorferi can
trigger the development of specific cutaneous infiltrates in patients with
B-CLLref.
Despite the malignant B cells typically express low-density membrane IgM
or IgM/IgD, CSR
is a frequent phenomenon in B-CLL, and a subset of the CLL lymphocytes
progress to later stages of B cell differentiation. In most cases switching
occurs to a1 and g3,
but CLL transcripts corresponding to the other g
chain isotypes are also detected. In one case both the productively and
nonproductively rearranged allele are found to undergo H chain CSR. CLL
g
transcripts are also present in surface IgG+ sorted B cells,
demonstrating that a small subset of the CLL cells express membrane IgG.
In addition, transcripts encoding secretary g2
and g3 H chains are detected in some
cases, which suggests that some serum IgG could be produced by the leukemic
clone. Analysis of sorted PBL shows that CSR occurs in CLL cells that express
the CD5 antigen. Finally, nucleotide sequence analysis showed that the
m,
a,
and g CLL transcripts are identical, demonstrating
that the CLL cells do not undergo SHM
in their V region genes after the H chain CSRref.
The leukemic cells of each patient have definable and often substantial
birth rates, varying from 0.1% to > 1.0% of the entire clone per day. Those
patients with birth rates > 0.35% per day are much more likely to exhibit
active or to develop progressive disease than those with lower birth rates
Thus, B-CLL is not a static disease that results simply from accumulation
of long-lived lymphocytes. Rather, it is a dynamic process composed also
of cells that proliferate and die, often at appreciable levelsref.
Symptoms &
signs : CLL follows an extremely variable clinical course with overall
survival times ranging from months to decades. Some patients have no or
minimal signs and symptoms during their entire disease course and have
a survival time similar to age-matched controls. Other patients experience
rapidly deteriorating blood counts and organomegaly and suffer from symptoms
at diagnosis or soon thereafter necessitating therapy.
-
lymphocytosis =>
-
lymphadenopathy =>
-
superficial
-
deep : phlebothrombosis, lymphedema, obstructive jaundice, hydronephrosis
-
hepatosplenomegaly =>
-
bone marrow infiltration (anemia, neutropenia, thrombocytopenia) =>
-
skin
-
gastrointestinal involvement (gastric ulcers/hemorrhages, malabsorption
enteritis, miliary pulmonary nodular infiltration, pleural effusion)
-
pulmonary apparatus
-
central nervous system =>
-
autoimmune diseases :
-
autoimmune
hemolytic anemia (AIHA)
occurs in approximately 10-25% of CLL patients at some time during the
course of the diseaseref1,
ref2,
ref3.
Although the pathogenic autoantibodies occasionally may be produced by
the malignant B-cell cloneref1,
ref2.
in most cases the autoantibodies appear to be made by remnant normal B
lymphocyteref1,
ref2.
This view is supported by the observation that the antibodies eluted from
the red blood cells (RBC) are typically “warm-reactive” polyclonal IgG
antibodies that display activity against monomorphic antigens of the rhesus
system. On the other hand, the antibodies produced by the B-CLL cells are
usually IgM and are always monoclonal. Experiments with SCID mice reconstituted
with peripheral blood lymphocytes from a B-CLL patient have also suggested
that the anti-RBC antibodies are not related to the malignant cloneref.
A large proportion of these animals developed human IgG anti-RBC autoantibodies
that were of polyclonal origin. Collectively, these data have suggested
that the anti-erythrocyte autoantibodies in B-CLL occur as a consequence
of progressive dilution or inhibition of nonneoplastic B or T lymphocytes
whose role is to antagonize the autoreactive Bcell clonesref1,
ref2.
This model, however, does not provide an explanation for the much higher
frequency of AIHA in CLL versus other hematologic malignancies and the
lack of correlation between the circulating levels of pathogenic anti-RBC
autoantibodies and the duration and severity of the underlying lymphoproliferative
disease : the expected frequency of 51p1 in CLL is approximately 15%, which
is significantly lower than the frequency observed in the CLL-AIHA patients
(47%). A significant correlation between VH gene usage and AIHA
was also observed for the DP-50 gene, which was not present among 75 surveyed
sequencesref,
but accounted for 33% of the B-CLL-AIHA sequencesref.
Interestingly, this VH gene has also been found in 5 of 14 investigated
human monoclonal anti-Rh(D) antibodies, indicating that it is also overrepresented
in the human anti-Rh(D) responseref.
The antibodies produced by the B-CLL cells could have a similar specificity
and could promote the binding of RBCs, sensitized with polyclonal IgG antibodies,
to the FcRs on macrophages. A subset of B-CLL cells produces secretory
g-chain
transcripts, which in 2 of the B-CLL-AIHA patients were predominantly of
the g2 and g3
H-chain isotype. Antibodies of the IgG3 subclass seem to play
an important role in the initial adherence of sensitized erythrocytes to
macrophages because of their greatest affinity for the FcgRIIIref.
Alternatively, the B-CLL antibodies might not bind directly to RBC antigens,
but could represent second antibodies that bind to the Fc portion of the
anti-RBC antibodies. Initial experiments with a recombinant Fv antibody
that corresponds to the CLL Ig of patient HA2 show low-affinity reactivity
against a number of self antigens including human IgG. Finally, the B-CLL
antibodies could have antiidiotypic activity and could stimulate normal
autoreactive B cells to produce anti-RBC antibodies. Antiidiotypic IgG
antibodies that crossreact with some anti-Rh(D) antibodies have been detected
in eluates from sensitized RBCs and have been implicated in the pathogenesis
of AIHAref
-
infections : reactivation of VZV

Clinical variants :
-
polyadenopathic systemic form (mainly lymph node involvement)
-
pure splenomegalic form (no lymphadenomegaly, favourable prognosis,
first reported by Binet in 1977)
-
dysimmunoglobulinic form
-
erythrolytic variant : severe AIHA due to anti-D antibodies
-
paraproteinemic or secretory form (5%) : monoclonal Ig in serum
-
thrombocytopenic form (autoimmune thrombocytopenia)
-
pure medullary form (very rare)
-
erythrodermic form (Sezary-like syndrome)
-
regional form (single organ or apparatus)
-
insect bite-like reaction and true hypersensitivity to mosquito bites
Laboratory
examinations :
-
k (60%) > l (40%)
-
the monoclonal B cells must represent the majority of leucocytes with an
absolute
lymphocyte count >5 · 109 cells/l and < 55% prolymphocytes,
which has persisted for at least 1 monthref
-
lymphocytosis > 30%
-
hypogammaglobulinemia (80% at diagnosis)
-
very high levels of sCD23
-
cytomorphology : small mature lymphoid cells, with high nuclear-to-cytoplasm
ratio, scant cytoplasm, and round nuclei with highly condensed chromatin
and inconspicuous nucleolus. Admixed with these cells may be prolymphocytes
and paraimmunoblasts, characterized by larger size and prominent nucleoli

Bone marrow infiltration pattern :
-
nodular (10%)
-
interstitial (40%)
-
diffuse (25%)
-
mixed (25%)
-
never intrasinusoidal (differential diagnosis with SMZL
)
-
immunophenotype : pan-T cell marker CD5+
(differential diagnosis with MCL
!)6+10
/ CALLA-11a+11c-19+20loFMC7lo21+22weak23+30-38+/-79blo
sIg (IgM or IgD)lo. CD5- B-CLLs represent <
5% of B-CLLs. When compared with CD5+ B-CLLs, more cases have
advanced disease, splenomegaly, and a cytologically mixed CLL pattern according
to the French-American-British (FAB) classification. In addition, CD23
expression is frequently absent, whereas FMC7 positivity and expression
of high amounts of SIg are more frequently observed than in CD5+
CLLref.
Thus, CD5- B-CLL seems to be intermediate between classical
CLL and prolymphocytic leukemiaref.
Immunohistochemically, B-CLL differs from SMZL
for a lower expression of CD20 and positivity for CD23
-
atypical CLL :
-
CD5-ref
-
CD8+ (< 0.5%)ref
-
CD11c+
-
CD20high
-
FMC7high
-
CD22high
-
CD23-
-
CD56+ref
-
CD154+ref
-
IgL high
-
cytogenetics :
-
trisomy 12 (MDM2
;
10-15% in conventional cytogenetics, 15% at FISH) : atypical/mixed-type
CLL requiring therapy, reduced survival
-
13q14- (10% in conventional cytogenetics, 53% at FISH) : typical
morphology, favorable prognosis
-
11q21- (8% at conventional cytogenetics, 19% at FISH) : typical
morphology, massive lymphadenopathy, young age, reduced survival
-
6q- (6% at conventional cytogenetics, 9% at FISH) : artpical morphology,
reduced survival
-
11q23- (20% : ATM
)
=> increased TfR
expression => more severe disease course, with earlier onset of symptoms,
shortened lymphocyte doubling time, poor response to therapy, and shortened
survival (may also partially explain why gallium, an atomically iron-like
toxic metal that binds to transferrin and the TfR is incorporated into
cells and was previously demonstrated to have anti-tumor activity in patients
with lymphomas refractory to other chemotherapeutic treatments)ref
-
17p- (4% at conventional cytogenetics, 8% at FISH : p53
)
: more common in atypical CLL and advanced stages of CLL, purine analog-refractary
-
t(11;14)(q13;q32) (2-3%) : mixed type (CLL/PLL), frequent transformation
into PLL, similar to leukemic MCL
-
t(14;19)(q32;q13) : very rare, atypical morphology, young age, aggressive
course
-
molecular biology : a signature of microRNA
(miRNA)
gene expression profiling (based on the development of a microchip containing
oligonucleotides corresponding to 245 miRNAs from human and mouse genomes)
correlates with diagnosis and prognosis of B-CLLref.
2 signatures are found : one correlates with mutations in the variable
region of the immunoglobulin gene—a good prognostic indicator, the other
correlated with the deletion of chr13q14—a region containing 2 small miRNA
genes that are downregulated in about 60% of CLL. There was only one common
denominator between these 2 signatures, and that was the downregulation
of miR-16, which is in fact the miR found deleted in CLLref.
miR-15a and miR-16-1 are deleted or down-regulated in the majority of CLLs.
miR-15a and miR-16-1 expression is inversely correlated to Bcl2 expression
in CLL and both microRNAs negatively regulate Bcl2 at a posttranscriptional
level. BCL2 repression by these microRNAs induces apoptopsis in a leukemic
cell line model. Therefore, miR-15 and miR-16 are natural antisense Bcl2
interactors that could be used for therapy of Bcl2-overexpressing tumorsref.
A unique microRNA expression signature composed of 13 genes (of 190 analyzed)
differentiates cases of B-CLL with low levels of ZAP-70 expression from
those with high levels and cases with unmutated IgVH from those
with mutated IgVH. The same microRNA signature is also associated
with the presence or absence of disease progression. A germ-line mutation
in the miR-16-1–miR-15a primary precursor causes low levels of microRNA
expression in vitro and in vivo and is associated with deletion
of the normal allele. Germ-line or somatic mutations are found in 5 of
42 sequenced microRNAs in 11 of 75 patients with CLL, but no such mutations
are found in 160 subjects without cancerref
-
abdominal and superficial lymph nodes echography
-
chest X-rays
-
CBC, SGOT, SGPT, total and direct bilirubin, alkaline phosphatase, gGT,
uricemia, glycemia, azotemia, cretininemia, serum protein electrophoresis,
b2-microglobulin,
LDH, ESR, PCR, hepatitis mosaic, direct and indirect Coombs tests, haptoglobin,
IgG, IgM, IgA, ANA, ENA, ANCA, anti-endomysium, anti-dsDNA antibodies,
RF
Differential
diagnosis : lymphoid disorders that can present as "chronic leukemia"
and be confused with typical B cell chronic lymphoid leukemia
Prognosis :
|
Binet's staging, 1981ref
|
criteria
|
Rai's staging, 1975ref
|
median survival, years
|
| A (80% at diagnosis) |
no lymphadenomegaly |
lymphocytosis
> 15,000/ml in peripheral blood or > 40% of
bone marrow cells |
0
|
>10
|
| 1 or 2 lymphoid areas involved (cervical, axillary, inguinofemoral,
or liver+spleen) |
lymphocytosis
+ lymphadenomegaly |
I
|
7
|
| B |
>= 3 lymphoid areas involved |
lymphocytosis
+ hepatomegaly
and/or splenomegaly |
II
|
< 5
|
| C (Fisher-Evans syndrome) |
autoimmune
hemolytic anemia (AIHA)
< 10 g/dl in females, < 11 g/dl in males (from activation of non-neoplastic
clones) independently from the number of lymphoid areas involved |
lymphocytosis
+ autoimmune
hemolytic anemia (AIHA)
(HGB > 11 g/dl; from activation of non-neoplastic clones) |
III
|
1.5-2
|
autoimmune
thrombocytopenia
< 100,000/ml (from activation of non-neoplastic
clones) independently from the number of lymphoid areas involved |
lymphocytosis
+ autoimmune
thrombocytopenia
(PLT > 100,000/ml; due to activation of non-neoplastic
clones) |
IV
|
1.5-2
|
However, there is heterogeneity in the course of the disease among individual
patients within a single stage group. Most importantly, the clinical staging
systems do not allow one to predict if and at what rate there will be
disease progression in an individual patient diagnosed with early stage
disease.
-
clinical patient characteristics such as age, gender and performance status
-
laboratory parameters reflecting the tumor burden or disease activity such
as :
-
absolute lymphocyte count
-
LDH
elevation
-
bone marrow infiltration pattern
-
lymphocyte doubling time (LDT)ref1,
ref2,
ref3
-
serum markers such as :
-
cytogenetics :
-
genomic aberrationsref
can be identified in about 80% of CLL cases by fluorescence in-situ
hybridization
(FISH) of interphase cell nuclei ("Interphase-Cytogenetics") with a
disease-specific comprehensive probe setref
:
|
low-risk
|
|
|
high-risk
|
|
13q- |
13q-single |
VH mutated |
6q- |
+12q |
17p- |
11q- |
VH unmutated |
| single center cohort of CLL patients distributed over all stages |
55% |
36% |
44% |
7% |
16% |
7% |
18% |
56% |
| CLL1 trial of the GCLLSG for untreated
Binet A patients with no classical indication for treatment |
59% |
40% |
59% |
2% |
13% |
4% |
10% |
41% |
| CLL4 trial (randomized F vs FC) of the GCLLSG
for untreated Binet B/C patients up to 65 years of age with indication
for treatment |
53% |
34% |
31% |
9% |
11% |
3% |
21% |
69% |
| CLL3 trial (early myeloablative radio-chemotherapy and autologous transplantation)
of the GCLLSG for Binet B/C patients
up to 60 years of age with maximum one line of prior therapy |
52% |
27% |
32% |
6% |
12% |
3% |
22% |
68% |
| CLL2H trial (subcutaneous alemtuzumab) of the GCLLSG
for fludarabine-refractory patients with indication for treatment |
48% |
14% |
19% |
9% |
18% |
27% |
32% |
81% |
Genomic aberrations provide insights into the pathogenesis of the disease
since they point to loci of candidate genes (17p13: p53; 11q22-q23: ATM)
and identify subgroups of patients with distinct clinical features. Specific
genomic aberrations have been associated with disease characteristics such
as marked lymphadenopathy (11q deletion) and resistance to treatment (17p
deletion). Moreover, such aberrations define specific subgroups that differ
in the rate of disease progression as determined by the time from diagnosis
to first treatment and the overall survival time of CLLref.
Probabilities of disease progression as assessed by the treatment-free
interval in the 5 dominant categories of genomic aberrations. The median
treatment-free intervals for the 17p deletion (n = 23), 11q deletion (n
= 56), 12q trisomy (n = 47), normal karyotype (n = 57), and 13q deletion
(single abnormality; n = 117) groups were 9, 13, 33, 49, and 92 months,
respectively :
Estimated survival probabilities from the date of diagnosis in 325
CLL patients divided into the 5 categories defined in a hierarchical model
of genomic aberrations in CLL. The median survival times for the 17p deletion
(n = 23), 11q deletion (n = 56), 12q trisomy (n = 47), normal karyotype
(n = 57), and 13q deletion (as single abnormality; n = 117) groups were
32, 79, 114, 111, and 133 months, respectively.
Relation of VH mutation status and genomic aberrations in
300 CLL casesref
:
|
VH mutated
|
VH unmutated
|
P-value at Fisher’s exact test
|
| clonal aberrations |
80% |
84% |
0.37 |
| 13q14 deletion appear to have a more favorable outcomeref |
65% |
48% |
0.004 |
| 13q deletion single |
50% |
26% |
< 0.001 |
| trisomy 12 |
15% |
19% |
0.44 |
| 11q23 deletion have been associated with a shorter median survivalref1,
ref2,
ref3,
ref4,
ref5,
ref6 |
4% |
27% |
< 0.001 |
| 17p deletion |
3% |
10% |
0.03 |
| 17p or 11q deletion |
7% |
35% |
< 0.001 |
VH mutation status and genomic aberrations are 2 separate
genetic parameters of prognostic relevance, but they appear to be correlated.
Unfavorable aberrations (11q-, 17p-) occur more frequently in VH
unmutated tumors, and favorable aberrations (13q-, 13q- single) occur more
frequently in the VH mutated subgroupref1,
ref2,
ref3.
This unbalanced distribution of genomic aberrations emphasizes the different
biological background of the CLL subgroups with mutated or unmutated VH
and could in part explain their different clinical course. On the other
hand, about 66% of the VH-unmutated CLL cases show no unfavorable
genomic aberrations, indicating a differential influence of these factors.
Incidence of genomic aberrations and VH mutation status
in one large single center fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) study
compared with preliminary results from prospective multicenter trials of
the German Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia (CLL) Study Group (GCLLSG) for
different clinical situations.
-
gene abnormalities (p53 and ATM)
-
CLL unmutated cases showed
a strikingly higher level of CLLU1
expression (several hundred fold) compared with mutated
ones, which in turn showed a median 5.7-fold up-regulation compared with
normal B cells.
-
the mutation status of the variable segments of immunoglobulin heavy
chain genes (VH), or surrogate markers for these factors (CD38,
ZAP-70, LPL, etc.)ref1,
ref2,
ref3,
ref4,
ref5,
ref6,
ref7,
ref8,
ref9
(Orchard J, Davis Z, Ibbotson R, Richards S, Catovsky D, Oscier D. Comparison
of ZAP-70, IgVH gene mutational status and CD38 in CLL patients requiring
therapy: preliminary report from the UK CLL IV trial [abstract]. Blood.
2003;102:#105). Although early studies of the IgH gene in CLL failed to
demonstrate somatic mutationref1,
ref2,
ref3,
ref4,
more recent analyses have shown that a substantial (20-50%) percentage
of cases show somatic mutations, suggesting that CLL may arise from either
pregerminal center naive B-cells, or germinal center exposed B-cellsref1,
ref2,
ref3,
ref4,
ref5.
These studies also suggest that the presence or frequency of somatic mutation
correlates with immunophenotyperef,
the usage of variable region gene (VH) familiesref
and the presence of specific chromosomal abnormalitiesref.
Fais et alref
reported somatic mutation in 50% of the IgM+ expressing cases,
with the highest incidence noted in the VH3 family, compared
with VH1 and VH4. Oscier et alref
noted that cases with trisomy 12 lacked somatic mutation, whereas cases
with 13q14 deletion showed significant levels of somatic mutation. The
existence of CLL lymphocytes having undergone somatic mutation suggests
that a subset of CLL is derived from memory B cells that have passed through
the germinal center stage of B-cell differentiation. Taken together, the
above observations indicate that CLL is more heterogeneous than previously
thought and may develop either from ontogenically naive B lymphocytes or
from a more mature antigen-exposed memory B cells. The mutation status
of the VH genes is one of the most important molecular genetic
parameters defining pathogenic and prognostic subgroups of CLLref1,
ref2
:
-
pregerminal center, unmutated
(VH homology > 98%) (50%) : unfavorable course with rapid
progression (estimated median survival time = 79 months)
-
germinal center, mutated (VH
homology < 98%) (50%) : slow progression and long survival (estimated
median survival time = 152 months)
However, genome-wide gene expression profiling studies revealed a surprisingly
homogeneous pattern of gene expression in both subtypes of CLL with only
a limited set of genes being differentially expressed in the subgroupsref1,
ref2.
Most importantly, it could be demonstrated that the VH mutation
status is clinically highly relevantref1,
ref2.
Survival curves for patients distributed over all stages (n = 300) and
separately for patients diagnosed with Binet stage A disease (n = 189)
from the largest published cohortref.
-
independent of the mutation status, the usage of specific VH
genes such as VH3-21 may be associated with an inferior
outcomeref.
To make the estimation of prognosis based on the VH status accessible
to the routine hematology laboratory, surrogate markers for the VH
status were identified :
-
originally, a correlation was observed between the VH mutation
status and CD38 expression of the CLL cells pointing to CD38 expression
as a prognostic markerref
-
based on genome-wide gene expression studies other surrogate markers such
as ZAP-70 expression were identified and validatedref1,
ref2.
ZAP-70 expression appears to strongly correlate with VH mutation
status and was therefore a strong prognostic marker in a pivotal studyref.
However, for both CD38 and ZAP-70, subsequent studies have yielded controversial
results with regard to their validity as a surrogate marker for VH
and prognostic indicator. The facts that ... :
-
divergent results have been obtained in different laboratories (CD38 and
ZAP-70)
-
the expression level may change over time (CD38)
-
a careful separation of T cells is necessary (ZAP-70)
-
different cut-off values to distinguish "positive" from "negative" cases
were defined (CD38 and ZAP-70)
-
approximately 10–30% of cases show discordant status for CD38 or ZAP-70
as compared to VH in all series described
... indicate that these markers may not be as reliable as initially thought
for routine diagnosticsref1,
ref2,
ref3,
ref4
(Orchard J, Davis Z, Ibbotson R, Richards S, Catovsky D, Oscier D. Comparison
of ZAP-70, IgVH gene mutational status and CD38 in CLL patients
requiring therapy: preliminary report from the UK CLL IV trial [abstract].
Blood. 2003;102:#105). Furthermore, the relationship of the VH
mutation status to other biological disease characteristics of potential
pathogenic relevance such as ongoing VH hypermutation as well
as VDJ diversification, telomere length, ability for BCR signaling, expression
of specific genes such as AID, and genomic aberrations are currently undergoing
examination. Levels of F-actin-capping
protein b subunit (CAPZB), 14-3-3b
protein / YWHAB, and laminin-binding
protein precursor / lectin, galactoside-binding, soluble, 3 (LGALS3)
were significantly increased in mutated B-CLL relative to unmutated B-CLL.
In addition, primary sequence data from tandem mass spectrometry showed
that nucleophosmin was present as several protein spots in M-CLL but was
not detected in unmutated B-CLL samples, suggesting that several post-translationally
modified forms of nucleophosmin vary between these 2 sample groups. No
specific differences were found between CD38+ and CD38-
patient samples using the same approachref.
IgG+ CLL is phenotypically similar to mutated
IgM+IgD+ CLL (M-CLL) and variably expressed CD38
(4 of 14). ZAP-70, a tyrosine kinase preferentially expressed in unmutated
CLL, was found in only 2 of 14 cases. The ability to signal via surface
IgM (sIgM) varies between the main subsets of CLL and is associated with
expression of ZAP-70. In IgG+ CLL, 9 of 14 responded to engagement
of sIgG with no apparent requirement for expression of CD38 or ZAP-70.
However, signal capacity correlated with intensity of sIgG expression.
Most switched immunoglobulin variable region genes were somatically mutated
without intraclonal variation, and no case expressed activation-induced
cytidine deaminase. Derivation from a postgerminal center B cell is, therefore,
likely, and a relationship with M-CLL is suggested. This is supported by
a shared biased usage of the V4-34 gene. Similar bias in normal B cells
developed with age, providing an expanded population for transforming events.
However, conserved sequences detected in the CDR3 of V4-34-encoded gamma
chains were not found M-CLL, indicating no direct path of isotype switch
from M-CLL. IgG+ CLL is likely to arise from an age-related
expanded pool of B cells, on a path parallel to M-CLL, and perhaps with
a similar clinical courseref
-
longer survival in individuals heterozygous for 1513AC P2X7
SNP, expecially in patients with mutated VH genesref.
P2X7 receptor triggers IL-1
maturation and exteriorizationref
-
ongoing CSR occurs in only a fraction of the CLL clone, as only small proportions
of CD5+CD19+ cells express surface IgG or IgA and
lack IgM and IgD.
The VH mutation status, 17p deletion, 11q deletion, age,
leukocyte count and LDH
were identified as independent prognostic factorsref.
When the VH mutation status and 11q and 17p aberrations were
included in the model, the clinical stage of disease according to the systems
of Rai or Binet was not identified as an independent prognostic factor
for survival, indicating that in the context of these genetic parameters,
the clinical stage of the disease may lose its independent prognostic valueref.
2 other independent series have confirmed the strong prognostic and independent
impact of VH mutation status and genomic aberrations on clinical
courseref1,
ref2.
Therefore, 4 subgroups of CLL with markedly differing survival probabilities
can be defined by the VH mutation status, 11q deletion and 17p
deletion. These molecular features also provide insight into the biological
bases of the clinical heterogeneity of CLL and may lead to future risk-adapted
treatment strategies for individual patients. Survival probabilities among
patients in the following genetic categories: 17p- (17p deletion irrespective
of VH mutation status), 11q- (11q deletion irrespective of VH
mutation status), unmutated VH (homology 98% and no 17p
or 11q deletion), and mutated VH (homology < 98% and no 17p
or 11q deletion)ref.
-
A) among all 300 patients estimated median survival times were: 17p- 30
months, 11q- 70 months, VH 98% 89 months. and VH
< 98% not reached (54% survival at 152 months)
-
B) in Binet A patients only (n = 189) estimated median survival times were:
17p- 36 months, 11q- 68 months, VH 98% 86 months months,
and VH < 98% not reached (52% survival at 152 months).
In order to further improve the understanding of molecular pathogenesis
and clinical outcome prediction in CLL, microarray platforms have been
developed as tools to evaluate genome wide parameters and defects. On the
genomic level matrix CGH (comparative genomic hybridization against a matrix
of defined DNA fragments) is a sensitive test allowing the detection of
novel recurrent aberrations of potential pathogenic and prognostic importanceref.
On the level of gene expression, comprehensive profiling studies of CLL
based on DNA chip technology have indicated that the global gene expression
"signature" of VH mutated and unmutated CLL is very similar
and that only the expression of a small number of genes discriminates between
the 2 groupsref1,
ref2.
In addition to the characterization of expression signatures associated
with the VH mutation subgroups of CLL a study of 100 CLL samples
characterized for VH status and genomic aberrations described
a significant number of differentially expressed genes clustering in chromosomal
regions affected by the respective genomic losses or gainsref.
Deletions affecting chromosome bands 11q22-q23 and 17p13 led to a reduced
expression of the genes in the corresponding genomic region, such as ATM
and p53, while trisomy 12 resulted in the upregulation of genes mapping
to chromosome arm 12q. The finding that the most significantly differentially
expressed genes were located in the corresponding aberrant chromosomal
regions suggests that a gene dosage effect may exert a pathogenic role
in CLL.
Validation of prognostic factors in prospective
trials : in retrospective series of heterogeneously treated patients
with CLL, the relationship between stage of disease and genetic parameters
was assessed. Distinct subgroups of CLL patients defined by specific genomic
aberrations showed significantly different rates of disease progression
as defined by the time from diagnosis to first treatment. In addition,
the prognostic impact of VH mutation status and genomic aberrations
with regard to overall survival was observed for patients both with early
stage (Binet A) and advanced stage disease. However, this data was derived
from heterogeneous single center cohorts of patients. Data from patients
prospectively enrolled in multicenter trials are just emerging.
Risk for progression in early stage CLL:
in the CLL1 trial of the
German CLL Study
Group (GCLLSG) CLL patients with Binet A disease are stratified into
a high risk arm if they have a LDT < 12 months and/or a diffuse bone
marrow infiltration pattern and a TK level > 7 U/L and/or ß2-MG
level > 3.5 mg/Lref.
Based on this stratification the high risk group is randomized between
immediate treatment with fludarabine versus watch and wait while the low-risk
group is followed up. In addition at enrollment genomic aberrations and
VH mutation status are analyzed. Table 1 gives a summary of
the genetic results obtained so far. These results show that high-risk
aberrations (11q- or 17p-: 14%) and unmutated VH (41%) occur
in a significant number of asymptomatic early stage patients. When comparing
the results from CLL1 with our single center study containing patients
diagnosed in all stages and the CLL4 study (fludarabine vs fludarabine/cyclophosphamide
for untreated Binet B/C patients, see also www.dcllsg.de) (Eichhorst B,
Busch R, Hopfinger G, et al. Fludarabine plus cyclophosphamide (FC) induces
higher remission rates and longer progression free survival (PFS) than
fludarabine (F) alone in first line therapy of advanced chronic lymphocytic
leukemia (CLL): results of a Phase III study (CLL4 Protocol) of the German
CLL Study Group (GCLLSG) [abstract]. Blood. 2003;102: #243.) it is interesting
to note that the incidence of low-risk markers (mutated VH,
13q- single) is higher and the percentage of high-risk markers (unmutated
VH, 11q-, 17p-) is lower. The low incidence of 11q- in the CLL1
trial as compared to the other studies is likely due to the strong association
of this abnormality with marked lymphadenopathy and rapid disease progression
leading to recruitment of such patients in a trial for advanced stage symptomatic
disease. In the CLL1 study preliminary correlations of genetic parameters
with progression-free survival (PFS) among untreated patients showed that
unmutated VH as well as +12q, 11q- and 17p- are associated with
more rapid disease progressionref.
Moreover, the genetic parameters and the other parameters used for risk
stratification appear to be correlated. Unmutated VH and high-risk
aberrations (17p-, 11q-, +12q) were significantly associated with the trial-defined
high-risk group and with the individual parameters defining this group.
However, there was discordance in 20–40% of cases between individual parameters,
i.e. among the trial-defined "high-risk" patients 37% had mutated VH,
while in the "low-risk" group 28% had unmutated VH. In univariate
analysis the following prognostic indicators were significant for a shorter
PFS: TK (P < .001), LDT (P = .001), lymphadenopathy (P = .002),
ß2-MG (P = .006), absolute lymphocytes (P = .004), unfavorable
genomic aberrations (11q-, 17p-, +12q) (P < .001) as well as unmutated
VH status (P = .003). In multivariate analysis TK, LDT, unfavorable
genomic aberrations (11q-, 17p-, +12q) as well as unmutated VH
status were identified as independent variables. Therefore, it appears
that a combination of several different factors may allow the best prediction
of an individual patient’s risk for disease progression. The future CLL7
trial will therefore include the parameters TK, LDT, genomic aberrations
and VH mutation status for initial risk stratification among
Binet A CLL patients. Furthermore, young early stage patients in the "high
risk" group as defined in the CLL1 trial or by genetic risk factors (unmutated
VH, 11q-, 17p-) and active disease as defined by National Cancer Institute
(NCI) criteria are eligible for the autologous and allogeneic transplantation
protocols of the GCLLSG. Progression-free survival (PFS) assessed according
to genetic markers in the multicenter prospective CLL1 trial of the GCLLSGref1,
ref2.
-
according to VH mutation status :
-
according to genomic aberrations :

Predictors for response to treatment and survival
in advanced stage CLL : the observation that the rate of disease
progression is associated with genomic aberrations and VH mutation
status indicates that these factors may determine the behavior of the disease.
However, overall survival reflects additional parameters such as response
to treatment. The fact that overall survival was inferior for the subgroups
with unmutated VH, 11q-, or 17p-, despite the fact that comparable
treatment modalities were used for patients with or without these markers,
suggests that response to therapy may be different in genetic subgroups.
In particular, the deletion 17p- and/or abnormalities of the p53 gene involved
in this aberration have been associated with failure after treatment with
alkylating agents, purine analogs and rituximab
ref1,
ref2,
ref3,
ref4.
In a chromosome banding study of patients treated in a prospective trial
based on alkylating agents, 17p aberrations were the only chromosomal aberration
of prognostic relevanceref.
An interphase-FISH study also showed that patients whose leukemia cells
showed a 17p-/p53 deletion had significantly shorter survival times than
patients without this aberration, and a relationship was found between
the deletion and the response to treatmentref.
While 56% of patients without p53 deletion went into remission after treatment
with purine-analogs, none of the patients with p53 deletion showed a response.
Similarly, the monoclonal anti-CD20 antibody rituximab
did not show efficacy in CLL with p53 deletionref.
In contrast, there is anecdotal evidence that durable therapeutic success
can be achieved in CLL with 17p-/p53 mutation using the monoclonal anti-CD52
antibody alemtuzumabref.
This observation has been expanded in a retrospectively evaluated series
of CLL cases mostly refractory to fludarabine therapyref.
Treatment with intravenous alemtuzumab resulted in a CR or PR in 11 of
36 (31%) and in 6 of 15 (40%) patients with p53 mutations or deletions.
In the CLL2H study of the GCLLSG (alemtuzumab
for fludarabine refractory CLL) a high incidence (27%) of 17p- aberrations
was observed, confirming the association of this abnormality with fludarabine-resistant
disease. An interim analysis of this ongoing prospective trial has shown
a response (CR or PR) in 10 of 21 VH unmutated, 5 of 10 11q-,
and 6 of 10 17p- cases, providing evidence from a controlled trial that
alemtuzumab may be effective in CLL with 17p-/p53 mutation. The observation
that in a multivariate analysis 17p-, 11q-, and unmutated VH were independent
adverse prognostic markers with regard to overall survival indicated that
these factors may be associated with different outcomes after treatment.
Support for this hypothesis requires prospective evaluation of the best
currently available prognostic markers in controlled clinical trials. VH
mutation status, genomic aberrations, ZAP-70, etc. are currently being
evaluated in different treatment trials from which so far only preliminary
data have been available (Orchard J, Davis Z, Ibbotson R, Richards S, Catovsky
D, Oscier D. Comparison of ZAP-70, IgVH gene mutational status and CD38
in CLL patients requiring therapy: preliminary report from the UK CLL IV
trial [abstract]. Blood. 2003;102:#105; Eichhorst B, Busch R, Hopfinger
G, et al. Fludarabine plus cyclophosphamide (FC) induces higher remission
rates and longer progression free survival (PFS) than fludarabine (F) alone
in first line therapy of advanced chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL): results
of a Phase III study (CLL4 Protocol) of the German CLL Study Group (GCLLSG)
[abstract]. Blood. 2003;102: #243; Maloum K, Magnac C, Cazin B, et al.
Expression of unmutated VH genes is a detrimental prognostic factor in
chronic lymphocytic leukemia. Predictive value of mutational IgVH gene
status for incomplete response and relapse after oral fludarabine phosphate
(fludara oral) and cyclophosphamide in previously untreated CLL patients
[abstract]. Blood. 2003;102:#110)
Clinical evolutions : more aggressive
B-cell cancers that develop in about 10% of affected persons. Progression
to more aggressive B-cell cancers in persons with CLL can result from either
clonal evolution or from an independent transforming eventref
:
-
Richter's syndrome (RS)) (5-10%,
high malignancy; Richter MN. Generalized reticular cell sarcoma of lymph
nodes associated with lymphatic leukemia. Am.J.Pathol. 6:285-292 (1928))
:
-
DLBCL
(most) : despite DLBCL is generally thought to arise from the B-CLL clone,
approximately 50% of the patients had genetically unrelated cancersref.
-
Hodgkin’s disease
variants (rare) arising probably only in VH mutated CLLref
While overall response rates to various therapeutic strategies can vary
between 5% and 43%, median survival for RS patients with cytotoxic therapy
is 5 to 8 months. Approximately 50% have an age > 60 years, haemoglobin
level < 11 g/dL, received > 2 prior therapies, LDH
levels > 1.5 time the upper limit of normal, and tumour size >5 cm. Approximately
40% of patients with RS have platelet counts < 100,000, their time to
transformation was > 5 years, and b2-microglobulin
levels were 3 times the upper limit of normal. 21% had a PST >1. Most subjects
had prior treatment, including chemotherapy alone (61%), chemotherapy +
rituximab
(36%) and immunotherapy alone with rituximab and campath (3%). Some patients
underwent subsequent allo-SCT in remission (7%), as salvage (6%) or as
auto-SCT in remission (2%). There were no significant differences between
the chemotherapy and chemotherapy/rituximab groups for either mean complete
response (11% vs. 13%, respectively) or mean overall response (34% vs.
47%, respectively). The combination of these treated RS patients gave a
complete response of 12% and an overall response of 39%, with a median
failure-free survival of 7.1 months (95% confidence interval [CI], 5-10
months). Median overall survival was 9.1 months (95% CI, 8-11 months) for
the full group of 143 RS patients. When divided according to subsequent
transplantation, the patients that received allo-SCT in remission showed
significantly (P =.004) greater survival than both the therapy responders
without SCT and those that received SCT. In multivariate analysis, of the
large range of significant factors for response and survival in the previously
treated patients, the significant risk factors for poor survival were PST
> 1 (P =.006), LDH
level > 1.5 times the upper limit of normal (P =.003), platelet
count below 100,000 (P =.012), tumour size > 5 cm (P =.022) and > 2 prior
therapies (P =.024). However, when the SCT was included in this multivariate
analysis, platelet count lost its significance, and the absence of allo-SCT
in remission became a significant risk factor for poor survival (P
=.002). As the use of chemotherapy with or without immunotherapy followed
by allo-SCT resulted in improved survival when compared with the other
therapies used in this trial, allogenic stem cell transplantation should
be offered to all RS patients with available donors as post-remission therapy.
At The University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center the incidence of
RS is 3.9%. The large cells of RS may arise through transformation of the
original CLL clone or represent a new neoplasm. RS may be triggered by
viral infections, such as HHV-4 / EBV
.
Trisomy 12 and chromosome 11 abnormalities, as well as multiple genetic
defects, have been described in patients with RS. These abnormalities may
cause CLL cells to proliferate and, by facilitating the acquisition of
new genetic abnormalities, to transform into RS cells. The therapeutic
strategies for RS typically include therapies developed for NHL or acute
lymphoblastic leukemia. The reported response rates with these therapies
are 5% to 43%, and the median survival duration ranges from 5 to 8 months.
The median overall survival duration at our institution of patients with
RS is 9.1 months (95% confidence interval, 7.8 to 11 months), and the median
FFS duration is 7.1 months (95% confidence interval, 5.1 to 10.4 months).
Patients appear to benefit from cytoreductive therapy consisting of chemotherapy
and immunotherapy, followed by allogeneic stem cell transplantation, as
postremission therapy. As part of a program aiming to cure RS, we are currently
conducting a clinical trial of oxaliplatin
,
fludarabine
,
and cytarabine
in combination with rituximab
and recommend postremission therapy, including allogeneic stem cell transplantation
in patients with available donorsref
-
B-cell prolymphocytic leukemia
(B-PLL) (5-10%; 60% of all PLLs)
Epidemiology : male-to-female ratio 4:1,
age > 60 years; 20-fold lower incidence than B-CLL; a relatively rare form
of chronic lymphoproliferative disease, first described by Galton in 1974ref.
Although PLL is considered to be distinct from CLL by many criteria, the
delineation between the 2 is not clearcut because some cases of CLL can
transform into PLLref
and most PLL cases studied appeared to evolve from the B-CLL cloneref.
Furthermore, mixed forms of CLL-PL have been identified in which the
number of prolymphocytes is 10-55%ref
Symptoms & signs : massive splenomegaly
and only rarely lymphadenopathy
Laboratory examinations :
-
k (70%) > l (30%)
-
according to French-American-British (FAB) diagnostic criteria, the hallmark
of the disease is the presence of > 55% (or > 15,000/ml)
circulating morphologically identified prolymphocytesref.
It is a distinct clinicopathological entity characterized by massive splenomegaly
without lymph node enlargement, frequent marked hyperleukocytosis (> 150,000/ml
in 60%; the majority of which are prolymphocytes), and associated anemia
and thrombocytopenia. Morphologically, prolymphocytes are large cells with
condensed nuclear chromatin and a prominent central nucleolus. The vast
majority of PLL are from the B-lineage origin and express high density
monotypic sIg, usually IgM with or without IgD, and the CD19, CD20, and
CD22 B cell marker (Catovsky D: Prolymphocytic leukemia, in Catovsky D,
Foa R (eds): The Lymphoid Leukemia. London, UK, Butterworths, 1990, p 438).
-
immunophenotype : CD5-/+(30%)19+20+FMC7+21+22+23-30-
sIghi
Prognosis is often poor (median survival =
24 months)
-
acute leukemias (rare) :
Therapy : because the
initiation of therapy for early stage patients has not been shown to prolong
survivalref,
therapeutic procedures traditionally have been aimed at palliation and
were instituted only for advanced stage or symptomatic disease. More recently,
however, highly effective and potentially curative approaches such as antibody-chemotherapy
and autologous or allogeneic stem cell transplantation have been developed.
The therapeutic options vary markedly with regard to efficacy, toxicity
and cost, and new risk-stratified algorithms of therapy are becoming increasingly
necessary. The definition of more accurate prognostic factors has made
possible a risk-adapted approach to therapy for patients with CLL akin
to what has been commonplace for patients with acute leukemia for years.
Clearly, one can define patient populations with wide divergent survival
expectations as one can with acute leukemia. However, in patients with
acute
myeloid leukemia (AML)
the outcome is quite black and white. Patients either are cured of their
disease or they are not. For patients with CLL, the outcome is closer to
shades of gray. With the possible exception of blood or marrow transplantation
(BMT), no one will be cured of their disease. Furthermore, the anticipated
survival for even the worst group of patients with CLL is several years.
Thus, the decision of when to initiate treatment and what type of therapy
to initiate with a CLL patient is not straightforward. In fact, treatment
of low-risk patients may actually have deleterious effects on survival
as has been shown by the French Cooperative Groupref.
Currently the decision to treat patients is based on multiple factors including
advanced clinical staging, symptomatic disease, burden of disease, age,
co-morbid illnesses, adverse prognostic factors, and availability of treatments
that alter survival. Patients in early clinical stages with enough poor
prognostic criteria could be considered candidates for enrollment in clinical
trials or therapies such as stem cell transplantation that offer the potential
for cure. Once the decision to treat a patient has been made, there are
multiple treatments known to be effective for CLL.
-
chlorambucil
0.1 mg/kg/day PO daily is the oldest and best-known treatment for CLL.
Emetogenic potential : level 1. 66 second malignancies in chlorambucil
arm over 72 months. 48 second malignancies in observation arms over 67
months. It can induce partial remissions (PR) in 60–70% of previously untreated
patients, but no significant complete remissions (CR)ref
-
chlorambucil
+ prednisone
:
-
chlorambucil 0.3 mg/kg/day PO days 1-5, prednisone 40 g/m2/day PO days
1-5. Repeat cycles every 28 days. Emetogenic potential days 1-5 level 1ref
-
chlorambucil 30 mg/m2 PO day 1, prednisone 80 mg/day PO days
1-5. Repeat cycle every 14 days. Severe/life-threatening hematologic toxicity
(25%), infection (7%), fever (2%), severe vomiting (3%). Emetogenic potential
: day 1 level 1. Infectious mortality : 2%ref
-
alkylator/anthracycline combinations are frequently used with similar and
perhaps better responses to those seen with chlorambucil, but no change
in survivalref
-
purine
analogues
are nucleoside analogues that inhibit DNA polymerase and ribonucleotide
reductase, promoting apoptosisref.
-
fludarabine
has been the most widely tested and used nucleoside analogue in CLL.
-
the efficacy of fludarabine was studied in a large North American intergroup
trial in which more than 500 patients were randomized to receive fludarabine,
chlorambucil, and fludarabine and chlorambucil. Overall response (OR) favored
the fludarabine group at 63% (20% CR + 43% PR) versus 37% (4% CR + 33%
PR)ref.
The median duration of remission and the median progression-free survival
(PFS) in the fludarabine group were 25 months and 20 months, respectively,
whereas both values were 14 months in the chlorambucil group (P < 0.001
for both comparisons)
-
Leporrier et al also reported their results in patients with previously
untreated CLL treated with either fludarabine or an anthracycline-containing
regimen (CAP [cyclophosphamide,
doxorubicin, prednisone]
or ChOP (cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin,
vincristine, prednisone)
).
938 patients (651 stage B and 287 stage C) were randomized in 73 centers.
Compared to ChOP and fludarabine, CAP induced lower overall remission rates
(58.2%; ChOP, 71.5%; fludarabine; 71.1%; P < .0001 for each), including
lower clinical remission rates (CAP, 15.2%; ChOP, 29.6%; fludarabine, 40.1%;
P = .003). By contrast, median survival time did not differ significantly
according to randomization (67, 70, and 69 months in the ChOP, CAP, and
fludarabine groups, respectively)ref.
-
fludarabine 25-30 mg/m2/day IV days 1-5 (phase 1/2 trial, 2
dose levels). Repeat cycle every 28 days. Grade 4 neutropenia (56%), FUO/minor
infection (13%), pnemonia+/-septicemia (9%), thrombocytopenia (25%), stomatitis
(2%), neuropathy (4%), nausea (3%), diarrhea (2%) => infectious mortality
(3%). Emetogenic potential : days 1-5 level 1ref
An important observation in all these trials is the higher percentage
of CRs seen in the fludarabine treated groups. Fludarabine is well
tolerated with major side effects being hematologic and immunologic toxicities.
Also seen is autoimmune
hemolytic anemia (AIHA)
and, at very high doses, significant neurotoxicity. The issue of treating
patients with fludarabine who have a history of AIHA or ITP
,
either primary or secondary to previous purine analogue therapy, is a topic
of continued controversy (Montillo M, Tedeschi S, O’Brien SM, Lerner S,
Morra E, Keating MJ. Autoimmune phenomena against hematopoietic cells and
myelosuppression in CLL treated with fludarabine - including regimens as
front-line therapy [abstract]. VIII International Workshop on CLL Programme
and Abstract Book. 1999;54. Abstract P091; Hall R, Bolan S, Orchard J,
Oscier D, Myint H, Hamblin TJ. Autoimmune phenomena following treating
with fludarabine [abstract]. VIII International Workshop on CLL Programme
and Abstract Book. 1999;58, Abstract P103). The decision to treat these
patients should be done with extreme caution and close monitoring.
-
cladribine (2-CdA)
: there is evidence that produces similar responses as fludarabine in both
previously treated and untreated populations. Juliusson and Liliemark reported
a 31% CR and 27% PR in 52 patients with previously treated CLL, with a
median PFS of 23 months for CR patients and 16 months for PR patients.
Toxicities were similar to those observed with fludarabineref.
Recently, Robak et al reported their experience with 2-CdA on 378 patients
with CLL. 194 patients were previously untreated and 184 had relapsed or
refractory disease. Results showed a CR of 45.4% and a PR of 82.5% in the
previously untreated group with a median survival of 19.4 months, and a
CR of 12.5% and PR of 48.4% in the previously treated group with a median
survival of 16.3 monthsref.
Ckadruvrube 0.12 mg/kg/day IV continuous infusion days 1-5. Repeat cycle
every 28 days. Grade 3-4 neutropenia (9%), severe infections (13%), minor
infections and FUO (34%), thrombocytopenia (23%) => infectious mortality
(7%), hemorrhagic mortality (6%). Emetogenic potential days 1-5 level 1ref
-
cladribine (2-CdA)
+ prednisone
: cladribrine 0.12 mg/kg/day IV over 2 hours days 1-5, prednisone 30 mg/m2/day
PO days 1-5, repeat cycle every 28 days for 3 courses, grade 3-4 neutropenia
(9%), anemia grade 1-2 (6%), grade 3-4 (2%), FUO/infection (56%), thrombocytopenia
(9%), eosinophilia (9%), autoimmune
hemolytic anemia (AIHA)
(6%: related-deaths in 3% of patients), hepatic (6%), skin reaction (6%),
CNS (2%), diarrhea (2%), nausea/vomiting (2%), neuropathy (2%) => herpes
zoster reactivation in 21% of patients, herpes simplex infections in 11%
of patients; URI or pneumonia in 30% of patients. Emetogenic potential
: days 1-5 level 1ref
The accumulating 2-CdA data is provocative but not much different from
the fludarabine data. Unfortunately, crossresistance is seen among all
the nucleoside analogues, so a sequential treatment algorithm is unlikely.
Reports of synergism between alkylators and nucleoside analogues by alkylators
inducing DNA damage and nucleoside analogues inhibiting DNA repair prompted
trials combining these 2 modalitiesref
(Koel U, Li L, Nowak B. Fludarabine and cyclophosphamide: synergistic cytotoxicity
associated with inhibition of interstrand cross-link removal [abstract].
Proc Am Ass Cancer Res. 1997;38:2). Early reports of the combination of
fludarabine
+ cyclophosphamide
showed higher OR rates than fludarabine alone in previously treated patients
with alkylators or fludarabineref1,
ref2,
ref3
(O’Brien SM, Kantarjian H, Beran M. Fludarabine and cyclophosphamide therapy
in chronic lymphocytic leukemia [abstract]. Blood. 1996;88:480).
-
cyclophosphamide 300 mg/m2/day IV over 1 hour days 1-3, fludarabine
30 mg/m2/day IV over 30 minutes days 1-3. Repeat cycle every
28-42 days. Neutropenia grade 3 (75%), grade 4 (48%), fever/infection (40%),
thrombocytopenia (19%), nausea/vomiting (6%), fatigue/aches (2%), rash
(2%) => documented sepsis or pneumonia (25%), FUO or neutropenic fever
(25%), 6 atypical infections were reported, herpes zoster infection (5$),
reactivation of herpes simplex (8%), 29% of patients at the 300 mg/m2 dose
level required a dose reduction of cyclophosphamideref
-
fludarabine
+ cyclophosphamide
+ filgrastim
: in a multicenter Phase II study conducted by ECOG, 36 patients
received cyclophosphamide 600 mg/m2 intravenous (iv) day 1 and
fludarabine 20 mg/m2 IV days 1 through 5, followed by filgrastim
5 mg/kg subcutaneous starting approximately day 8. 15 of 36 (41.7%) evaluable
patients achieved complete response and 8 (22.2%) achieved a partial response,
giving an OR rate of 63.9% (90% CI: 48.4%, 77.2%) (Flinn IW, Jemiai Y,
Bennett JM, et al. Fludarabine and cyclophosphamide achieves high complete
response rate in patients with previously untreated chronic lymphocytic
leukemia: E1997 [abstract]. Blood. 2001;98:633a)
-
Preliminary results from a North American Intergroup trial comparing this
combination regimen to single-agent fludarabine revealed the combination
produced a superior CR rate compared to fludarabine alone, 23% versus 6%,
respectively
-
Alternative regimens using 3-day schedules of fludarabine and cyclophosphamide
have produced encouraging results. The German CLL Study Group noted a higher
CR rate with fludarabine and cyclophosphamide than with fludarabine alone
(20.2% vs 8.6%) (Eichhorst B, Busch R, Hopfinger G, et al. Fludarabine
+ cyclophosphamide induces higher remission rates and longer progression
free survival than fludarabine alone in first line therapy of advanced
chronic lymphocytic leukemia: results of a Phase III study (CLL4 Protocol)
[abstract]. Blood. 2003;102:72a). While these CR rates were disappointingly
low in both arms, the difference in response translated into a longer PFS
in the combination arm. In a single center Phase II arm study, CR rates
were not found to be substantially increased. However, the quality of these
CRs was improved, since only 8% of CR patients demonstrated residual CD5+
cells in the marrow compared with 33% after fludarabine
and prednisone
ref.
Taken together these studies suggest that the combination of fludarabine
and cyclophosphamide improves CR in patients with previously untreated
CLL. However, it is not clear as to what regimen might serve as the best
backbone by which to add new agents such as rituximab
.
Numerous other fludarabine combination regimens have been tested with promising
results in Phase II trialsref1,
ref2,
ref3.
-
single-agent antibodies :
-
anti-CD20 mAbs
: rituximab
has afforded excellent responses in patients with B-cell lymphomas. Early
disappointing results in small lymphocytic leukemia (SLL)/CLL from the
pivotal trial led to skepticism about its ultimate utility in CLL. However,
subsequent studies examining alternative schedules, doses, and patient
populations have clearly demonstrated rituximab’s efficacy in CLL. One
explanation for the meager response rates in patients with SLL is the low
serum trough levels seen in these patients, which are known to be inversely
related to response rates. To overcome the apparent altered pharmacokinetics,
the antibody has been given thrice weekly for 4 weeks at standard doses
(375 mg/m2) as well as very large single doses weekly for
4 doses. The thrice weekly regimen has resulted in 45% OR rate in patients
with previously treated CLLref.
5 of 6 previously untreated patients responded. A dose escalation study
has also been completed in which cohorts of patients with CLL and other
mature B cell malignancies received increasing doses of rituximab weekly
for 4 doses. Response correlated with dose and 75% of patients at the highest
dose (2250 mg/m2) respondedref.
44 previously untreated patients with CLL/SLL received rituximab 375 mg/m2
weekly for 4 consecutive weeks. All patients were required to have one
or more indications for treatmentref.
Patients with objective response or stable disease continued to receive
identical 4-week rituximab courses at 6-month intervals, for a total of
4 courses. The response rate after the first course of rituximab was 51%
(4% CR). While many patients treated with rituximab will respond, these
are predominantly partial responses, with the bone marrow being the most
difficult compartment to treat adequately. Grade 3 anemia (3%), grade 3-4
infection (17%), grade 3 flu-like symptoms (14%), grade 3 abnormal liver
function (7%), grade 3 hypotension (7%), grade 3 pulmonary (7%), grade
3 bone pain (3%), skin grade 3 (3%) and 4 (zoster : 3%). Due to a fatal
treatment-related complication, the 375 mg/m2 dose in week 1 was fractionated.
Patients received 50 mg on day 1, 150 mg on day 2, and the remainder of
the dose on day 3. 1 patient died of late pulmonary aspergillosis. Emetogenic
potential level 1ref
-
anti-CD52
mAbs
: alemtuzumab
-
30 mg IV over 2 hours 3 times a week (initiate dosing at
3 mg IV daily; when tolerated (infusion-related toxicities are < grade
2) increase to 10 mg). When the 10 mg dose is tolerated, the maintenance
dose of alemtuzumab 30 mg can be initiated. Maintain at 30 mg 3 times a
week for up to 12 weeks. Grade 3-4 neutropenia (64%), grade 1-2 anemia
(42%), grade 3-4 anemia (38%), grade 3-4 sepsis (10%), fever (19%), bronchitis/pneumonitis
(13%), pneumonia (10%), thrombocytopenia (50%), rigors (16%), dyspnea (9%),
fatigue (5%), hypotension (5%), urticaria (5%). Gradual escalation to the
recommended maintenance dose is required at the initiation of therapy and
after interruption of therapy for 7 days or longer. Hematological toxicity
is common. In patients with heavily pretreated B-CLL, a response rate of
30–40% has been reported with a median response duration of 12 months.
The toxicity related to the infusion of the antibody has hampered
its early use in patients.
-
30 mg subcutaneously 3 times a week up to a maximum of 18
weeks; dosing was initiated at 3 mg on day 1, 10 mg on day 2, and then
to full dose of 30 mg on day 5 if tolerated. In a Phase II study of previously
untreated patients given alemtuzumab for 18 weeks, an OR of 87% (95% CI,
76%–98%; CR, 19%; PR, 68%) was achieved in 38 evaluable patients (81% of
intent-to-treat population). CLL cells were cleared from blood in 95% patients
in a median time of 21 days. CR or nodular PR in the bone marrow was achieved
in 66% of the patients and most patients achieved this after 18 weeks of
treatment. An 87% OR (29% CR) was achieved in the lymph nodes. Transient
injection site skin reactions were seen in 90% of patients (grade 3 in
2%). Rigor, rash, nausea, dyspnea, and hypotension were rare or absent.
Grade 2-3 neutropenia (53%), grade 4 neutropenia (21%), anemia grade 0-1
(61%) or 2-3 (39%), grade 3 fever (2%), thrombocytopenia (grade 2-3 : 11%;
grade 4 : 5%), grade 3 fatigue (2%), grade 3 rigor (2% : much lower than
in IV administration !), the incidence of hypotension is significantly
reduced. Upward titration to ful dose was achieved by 31% of patients during
week 1. 88% of patients had grade 1-2 local injection site reaction. Therapy
was temporarily stopped in 7 patients due to neutropenia. Reactivation
of CMV in 4 patientsref.
Emetogenic potential : level 1. Appropriate premedication. Alemtuzumab
induces a profound lymphopenia, which may have contributed to the high
incidence of infectious complications seen in the early studies. This risk
has been substantially reduced by the use of prophylactic trimethoprim/sulfamethoxazole
,
acyclovir
,
and fluconazole
.
Prophylaxis against PCP and herpes virus infections is strongly recommended,
and should continue for 2 months after completion of alemtuzumab therapy,
or until the CD4+ is >= 200 cells/ml,
whichever is later. In this study of previously untreated patients infections
were rare, but 10% of patients developed cytomegalovirus
(CMV)
reactivation. In contrast to rituximab, alemtuzumab has its most pronounced
effects in blood and bone marrow, with minimal effect on bulky disease.
Subcutaneous administration of MabCampath shows similar efficacy as the
intravenous application. Most importantly alemtuzumab is active in high
risk CLL as defined by the presence of 17p- deletion.' (Stilgenbauer).
The median survival by FISH category after a median follow-up of 70 months
is: for ‘abnormality 17p-‘ median survival 2.5 years; for ‘no abnormality'
median survival 9 years; and for ‘abnormality 13q-‘ median survival 11
years. Also, the median survival for patients with early stage disease
with non-mutated IgVH gene - detected by FACS of peripheral
blood - have been reported to be about 8 years, whereas patients with early-stage
disease with mutated-type clones have a median survival > 24 yearsref.
(See Shanafelt TA, Call TG. Mayo Clin Proc. 2004;79:388-398)
Campath-1 has shown significant and durable effects in the treatment
in patients with previously treated, recurrent, indolent CLL. A 42% overall
response rate was achieved among 29 patients in one phase III studyref.
Other encouraging results have demonstrated the efficacy of campath-1 for
patients suffering from fludarabine refractory diseaseref,
and a 73% response rate observed among a limited number of patients with
prolymphocytic
leukemiaref
The increased specificity of mAbs for CLL compared to chemotherapy with
relative sparing of normal tissues has raised the question as to whether
MABs could be used as adjuvants to chemotherapy to target MRD or in a maintenance
approach to maintain remissions.
-
rituximab has been used in other low-grade lymphoid malignancies for
maintenance and it has prevented relapse but the duration of rituximab
benefit was not superior to using the antibody when patients relapsedref.
In patients with CLL, PFS (18.6 months) was relatively poor when rituximab
was used as front-line therapy and then administered at 6 month intervals
as maintenanceref.
Further investigation is needed to learn whether rituximab might be useful
in this setting if used at different doses or schedules.
-
the efficacy and safety of alemtuzumab in patients with CLL who had residual
disease after chemotherapy have also been investigated. Alemtuzumab was
administered to 41 patients 3 times weekly for 4 weeks in a Phase I/II
study following maximum response to induction chemotherapy. The OR was
46%. The major reason for failure to respond was the presence of adenopathy.
Residual bone marrow disease cleared in most patients, and 11 of 29 patients
(38%) achieved a molecular disease remission. Infections were reported
to occur in 15 patients (37%), and 9 of these infections were reactivation
of CMV. 3 patients developed EBV+, large cell lymphomaref.
Given the significant infectious toxicity, larger studies are needed before
this approach can be used on a routine basis.
-
combination chemo-immunotherapy : the encouraging high rate of durable
responses seen with fludarabine-based regimens may be further improved
by the addition of other novel agents.
-
fludarabine
+ cyclophosphamide
+ rituximab
(FCR) is currently under investigation as a first-line therapy for
patients with CLL. A single center study has shown good preliminary results
including a 71% CR rate (Keating MJ, O’Brien S, Lerner S, Wierda W, Kantarjian
H. Chemoimmunotherapy with fludarabine (F), cyclophosphamide (C), and rituximab
(R) improves complete response (CR), remission duration and survival as
initial therapy of chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) [abstract]. J Clin
Oncol. 2004;23:571), with 57% of complete responders tested (35/61 patients)
showing molecular remission (Keating M, Manshouri T, O’Brien S, et al.
A high proportion of molecular remission can be obtained with a fludarabine,
cyclophosphamide, rituximab combination in chronic lymphocytic leukemia
[abstract]. Blood. 2002;100:205a.)
-
pentostatin
+ cyclophosphamide
+ rituximab
: cyclophosphamide 600 mg/m2 IV day 1 followed by pentostatin
4 mg/m2 IV day 1, rituximab 375 mg/m2 IV day 1. Repeat
cycles every 21 days. Appropriate premedications. For cycle 1, patients
did not receive rituximab. Prophylaxis with trimethoprim/sulfamethoxazole
and acyclovir were administered to all recipients. Prophylactic filgrastim
was administered to all patients. Grade 3-4 neutropenia (45%), infection
(15%), thrombocytopenia (5%). Emetogenic potential day 1 level 5 (Weiss
MA et al, Blood 2003, 102, 673a, Abstract 2494)
-
fludarabine
+ rituximab
(FR) in combination have also been reported to result in very high
response rates in previously untreated patients with CLL, with CRs seen
in 33% of patients when FR was administered concurrently. The CR rate improved
to 47% when responding patients were consolidated with rituximabref.
-
cycle 1 : fludarabine 25 mg/m2/day IV over 20-30 minutes days
1-5
-
rituximab 50 mg/m2 IV day 1 infused over 4 hours with no rate
escalation
-
rituximab 325 mg/m2 IV day 3 infused at an initial rate of 50
mg/hour and increaased in 50 mg/hour increments every 30 minutes to a maximum
rate of 400 mg/hour as tolerated.
-
rituximab 375 mg/m2 IV day 5 infused at a rate of 100 mg/hour
for the first 15 minutes and then rate increased to infuse remainder over
the next 45 minutes
Neutropenia grade 3 (33%) or 4 (43%), anemia grade 1 (47%), 2 (18%), or
3 (4%), grade 3 infection (20%), thrombocytopenia (20%), dyspnea (14%),
grade 3 hypotension (6%)
-
cycles 2-6 : fludarabine 25 mg/m2/day IV over 20-30 minutes
days 1-5, rituximab 375 mg/m2 IV day 1 infused at a rate of
100 mg/hour for the first 15 minutes and then rate increased to infuse
remainder over the next 45 minutes. Repeat cycle every 28 days. Appropriate
premedications. Neutropenia grade 3 (11%) or 4 (8%). anemia grade 1 (14%),
2 (5%) or 4 (3%), grade 3-4 infection (6%), grade 3 dyspnea (6%)
8 opportunistic infections noted. 3 cases of grade 3-4 pulmonary toxicity.
Emetogenic potential days 1-5 level 1. This group retrospectively compared
the treatment outcome of the patients on this trial (n = 104) to patients
with similar clinical characteristics enrolled on a US Intergroup who received
fludarabine alone (n = 178). In multivariate analyses controlling for pretreatment
characteristics, the patients receiving fludarabine and rituximab had a
significantly better PFS (P < 0.0001) and overall survival (OS) (P =
0.0006) than patients receiving fludarabine therapy. 2-year PFS probabilities
were 0.67 versus 0.45, and 2-year OS probabilities were 0.93 versus 0.81.
Infectious toxicity was similar between the 2 treatment approaches